• 3 Posts
  • 6 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 12th, 2023

help-circle




  • Yes I did read the article. I’m not saying that she shouldn’t have replaced her vehicle, in fact she probably did make the smartest choice by going for a second hand EV. I’m just frustrated by the people that assume an electric vehicle is somehow “good” for the environment when it is not.

    She refers to her car in the following ways:

    • “a car that [does] not emit pollution” 
    • “Zero emission gave me peace of mind that I made the right choice for a world facing climate change”
    • “earth-friendly”

    Also this statement shows she is concerned about the environment:

    “suddenly remembered my intention for buying an EV in the first place. I should have spoken up. Greenhouse gas emissions, carbon dioxide, climate crisis … These words jumbled in my head. Nobody had even mentioned this life-or-death issue we all are facing.”

    But EVs are not some sort of silver bullet for the climate crisis. Do we yet have any studies confirming that they are better for the environment over ICE vehicles when considering lithium mining, vehicle production, battery replacement, tire pollution etc?

    I hope that the EV revolution is a net positive solution over ICE vehicles, but they are not some sort of magical product that is going to save the planet.